I loved how easy this shampoo applied and rinsed, with color lasting longer than expected, but the shade was inaccurate.

2026-01-21 Shampoo reviews Categroy：Men's Views：72

I appreciated the effortless application and extended color durability of this shampoo, though the Chestnut Brown shade had noticeable red undertones that I didn't like, leading me to consider another brown option in the future.

This is a review from Amazon.com about product:

Herbishh Hair Color Shampoo for Gray Hair – Magic Hair Dye Shampoo – Colors Hair in Minutes–Long Lasting–500 Ml–3-In-1 Hair Color–Ammonia-Free (Black)

My Shampoo Review: Easy Use, Long-Lasting Color Surprise

I loved the ease of applying, and shampooing out. The color lasted longer then I expected. I been coloring my hair for years, with box dyes. This was better EXCEPT the color. I chose Chestnut Brown, and with box dyes I have used this color often. this was not Chestnut Brown........ My hair had alot of RED tones in it, with Herbish. Not a fan of that at all! I will use it up and order a different brown next time.

Shampoo Basics & Tips

Understanding Shampoo Application and Color Longevity

Shampoo is a hair care product designed to cleanse the scalp and hair by removing dirt, oil, and product buildup. Its ease of application, as mentioned in the review, often depends on factors like viscosity and ingredient formulation. For color-treated hair, shampoos with gentle surfactants can make the process smoother, reducing tangles and effort during rinsing. Color longevity refers to how long the dye remains vibrant without fading, which can be influenced by the shampoo's pH balance and the presence of color-locking agents. In this case, the user noted the color lasted longer than expected, which might be due to formulas that minimize stripping of dyes through mild cleansing actions.

Box Dyes vs. Professional Hair Color

Box dyes are over-the-counter hair coloring kits that include everything needed for at-home use, such as dye, developer, and instructions. They are popular for their convenience and affordability but can vary in quality and color accuracy. Compared to professional salon treatments, box dyes may use simpler formulations that lead to inconsistent results, like the unexpected red tones described. Professionals often customize colors based on hair type and condition, reducing risks of off-tones. The review highlights that this shampoo-based color was better in some aspects than box dyes, possibly due to improved ease and durability, but still fell short in color matching.

Explaining Chestnut Brown and Red Tones in Hair Color

Chestnut Brown is a warm, medium brown hair color with subtle reddish or golden undertones, often described as rich and natural. However, variations can occur due to factors like underlying hair pigment, previous dye history, or product formulation. Red tones may emerge if the dye formula has more warm pigments or if the user's natural hair has underlying red pigments (common in darker hair). This can be unintentional, as seen in the review where "Herbish" might refer to herbal ingredients that sometimes enhance warm tones. To avoid this, users should perform strand tests and choose colors with neutral or cool undertones if red is undesirable.

Common Shampoo Knowledge and FAQs

Shampoos come in various types, such as clarifying, moisturizing, or color-safe, each tailored to different hair needs. Color-safe shampoos often contain sulfates-free formulas to prevent fading and maintain vibrancy. Everyday issues include color fading from sun exposure, hard water, or frequent washing. To extend color life, use lukewarm water and avoid daily shampooing. Additionally, patch testing new products can prevent allergic reactions or color mismatches. For those with color concerns, consulting a professional or reading reviews can help select the right shade, as the user plans to do by ordering a different brown next time.