Shampoo reviewsMen'sThis gentle shampoo dramatically reduces my scalp shedding, outperforming harsh medicated treatments with its effective routine.

This gentle shampoo dramatically reduces my scalp shedding, outperforming harsh medicated treatments with its effective routine.

2025-07-30 Shampoo reviews Categroy:Men's Views:50


Ditching salicylic acid shampoos that caused weekly scalp shedding was crucial. This gentle formula, combined with my 10-minute soak, DHS Tar alternation, sulfate-free wash, and cool ACV rinse, delivers real results where medicated treatments failed.


This is a review from Amazon.com about product:


Nizoral Anti-Dandruff Shampoo with 1% Ketoconazole, Fresh Scent, 14 Fl Oz


My Scalp Savior Shampoo Beats Salicylic Acid


Helps so much more with this ingredient than the ones with salicylic acid in it. That just makes my scalp completely shed once a week which is the LAST thing I need. I only wash my hair every three days. I do it in the tub so I can let it sit on my scalp for ten minutes. We have a spray nozzle so I can rinse with that. (I alternate with DHS Tar shampoo in three days.) Then I wash again with regular sulfate free shampoo. Use conditioner, then rinse with cool water with apple cider vinegar in it. Sounds like a lot of trouble, but IT WORKS! Even medicated stuff from dermatologist that you drip on the scalp didn’t work. Maybe you have to be bald for that to help.


Shampoo Basics & Tips


Understanding Scalp Shedding and Shampoo Ingredients


Salicylic Acid: A beta-hydroxy acid (BHA) used in shampoos to exfoliate the scalp and treat dandruff or seborrheic dermatitis by breaking down dead skin cells and unclogging follicles. While effective for some, it can be overly drying or irritating for sensitive scalps, potentially leading to increased flaking or shedding (desquamation) as noted in the review. Its keratolytic action might accelerate skin cell turnover excessively in some individuals.


Coal Tar (DHS Tar Shampoo)


An active ingredient derived from coal, used for decades to treat psoriasis, seborrheic dermatitis, and severe dandruff. It works by slowing down the rapid growth of skin cells on the scalp and reducing inflammation, scaling, and itching. It has a strong odor and can stain fabrics or light hair. Users often alternate it with other shampoos, as mentioned, due to its potency or smell.


Sulfate-Free Shampoo


Shampoos formulated without harsh surfactants like sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) or sodium laureth sulfate (SLES). Sulfates create rich lather but can strip natural oils, leading to dryness, irritation, and color fading. Sulfate-free options are gentler, making them ideal for sensitive scalps, color-treated hair, curly hair, or following treatments like coal tar, as used in the reviewer's routine to avoid further dryness.


Apple Cider Vinegar (ACV) Rinse


A diluted solution of apple cider vinegar and cool water used as a final hair rinse. ACV is acidic (pH 2-3), helping to:


How to Use: Dilute 1-2 tablespoons of raw, unfiltered ACV in 1 cup of cool water. Pour over hair after conditioning, massage scalp briefly, then rinse thoroughly or leave in. Start with lower concentrations.


Scalp Shedding (Desquamation)


This refers to the flaking or peeling of skin cells from the scalp. Some shedding is normal (exfoliation), but excessive shedding appears as visible dandruff or flakes. Causes include:


Common Shampoo & Scalp Questions


Q: How often should I wash my hair for a healthy scalp?
A: It varies greatly (daily to weekly). Factors include scalp oiliness, activity level, hair type, and conditions like dandruff. Washing removes buildup but overwashing can strip oils. The reviewer's every 3-day wash is common for managing scalp conditions without overdrying.


Q: What's the difference between dandruff and dry scalp?
A: Both cause flakes but differ. Dry scalp flakes are small, white, and due to lack of moisture; scalp feels tight. Dandruff (often seborrheic dermatitis) involves larger, oily, yellowish flakes, redness, and itching, caused by yeast/oil interaction. Treatments differ: moisturizing for dry scalp; antifungal/anti-inflammatory (like zinc pyrithione, selenium sulfide, ketoconazole, coal tar) for dandruff.


Q: Why let shampoo sit on the scalp?
A> For medicated shampoos (anti-dandruff, coal tar, salicylic acid), contact time is crucial (often 5-10 mins, per instructions) allowing active ingredients to penetrate and work effectively on the scalp skin, as the reviewer does.


Q: Are natural remedies like ACV effective?
A> ACV rinses can help manage mild scalp issues by balancing pH and removing buildup, as seen in the review. However, severe conditions like psoriasis or stubborn seborrheic dermatitis usually require medically proven treatments. ACV is a complementary step, not a replacement for diagnosed conditions.



This shampoo added body to my color-treated hair, though brushing felt less smooth than usual. Scent was unique but faded quickly.

My color-treated hair gained extra volume with this shampoo, but brushing required more effort than my smoothing routine. The unusual fragrance didn't linger long, yet it performed as claimed for body boost.

Read More...


This purple shampoo banishes brassiness beautifully without staining hands – and the scent keeps me hooked!

I love this purple shampoo for fighting brassiness without staining my hands, and its fantastic scent makes every wash enjoyable, even if it needs a bit more time than others.

Read More...


I cut daily hair loss by half but got flat, greasy strands and strong Pine-Sol scent lingering.

This shampoo slashed my hair fall dramatically, yet left straight thin hair greasy within 24 hours and flat with static. Pine-Sol scent lingers until next wash—better for dry curly types.

Read More...


This shampoo makes my hair soft, silky, shiny, and frizz-free instantly.

After using this shampoo, my hair became wonderfully soft, silky, and shiny; it's lightweight, stops flyaways, and feels smooth, making it my top choice for daily care. (20 words)

Read More...


This shampoo defines my curls, adds shine, and cleans gently despite needing extra product for lather.

My hair feels soft, looks shiny, and stays clean with enhanced natural curls after using this shampoo. However, low lather means I use more product, reducing value.

Read More...


I love this shampoo for my white hair, but its bottle cracks easily if dropped in the shower.

This shampoo is fantastic for maintaining my beautiful white hair color and health. However, the bottle is too fragile and cracked when I dropped it in the wet shower, which is disappointing.

Read More...



Tags: scalp shedding salicylic acid sulfate-free shampoo apple cider vinegar rinse coal tar shampoo


People who viewed this article also viewed

I love this shampoo—no more itching, less hair fall, great scent, and the conditioning bar saves my dry hair.

I found the best fragrance-free shampoo that keeps my hair soft without drying my scalp.

This sulfate-free shampoo stopped my scalp irritation while adding natural body for easy styling - worth every penny!

I love how these shampoo bars make my hair soft, shiny, and odor-free while extending wash days effortlessly.

I love this hydrating shampoo for voluminous hair, though I wish the conditioner mix-up didn't leave me stranded.

This shampoo failed my oily hair despite perfect application - here's why.

This shampoo cleanses thoroughly while delivering a delicate spa-like aroma that elevates my daily hair routine.

This shampoo left my hair incredibly soft, though the conditioner pump arrived broken and the tea tree scent is subtle.

This shampoo transformed my bleached frizz into soft, manageable hair effortlessly.

I love my salon-recommended R&Co shampoo for its heavenly fragrance and silky hair transformation – an Amazon gem!


Related articles

I love how this shampoo eliminates frizz, leaves my hair soft and silky, and removes styling product needs.

My stylist's shampoo stopped hair loss, giving me thicker, longer locks in just five months.

I feared oily hair but got amazingly soft, lightweight locks that surprised me delightfully.

My thick, dry hair felt weighed down with stiff residue after poor lathering and distribution.

Routine Shampoo reduced my shedding and transformed coarse, graying hair into silky manageable locks effortlessly.

My hair stopped falling out after using this shampoo regimen - life-changing results worth recommending!

One wash gave me incredibly soft, shiny hair with a lasting, delightful fragrance I adore.

After three weeks, I adore this shampoo set's quality and best-smelling conditioner for perfect hair.

My hair practitioner recommended this tea tree shampoo for thin hair and dry scalp; it helped tremendously, I highly recommend.

I loved the amazing scent and super clean scalp feel, though hair tangled initially until conditioner smoothed it perfectly.


More Shampoo reviews In Shampoo Say Website


Previous: Routine Shampoo reduced my shedding and transformed coarse, graying hair into silky manageable locks effortlessly.

Next: My hair stopped falling out after using this shampoo regimen - life-changing results worth recommending!

Contact us
Shampoo Say
Email: zy950124@163.com

Comments(0)

Previous 1 Next